Any interest in a concrit meme?

[anneapocalypse]

Since we've got our lovely kink/gen memes going on here, I'm wondering if anybody has interest in a space on this comm where people can request critique on their writing--meme fills or otherwise. Strictly voluntary, moderated, you'd get to specify what level of crit you wanted and in what areas as applicable, all that good stuff.

Tumblr's a great place for getting supportive feedback and recs and all that really nice stuff, but I know that I personally would love to be able to solicit more critical feedback to help improve my writing, and maybe there are others who feel the same.

This is a pretty good model of the sort of thing I'm envisioning, but not limited to kinkmeme fills and tailored to whatever the needs of our community may be.

Thoughts?
 

Comments

[katiejensen]

This sounds fantastic! I tended to avoid giving critiques on fic reblogs on tumblr because I never knew if the OP wanted crit, but this sounds like a great solution.

[anneapocalypse]

I feel the same way--I don't like to give unwanted critique, especially to people I don't know very well.

[akisawana]

I'd love a concrit meme!

[madparalian]

This is a great idea! I also rarely leave concrit on fics {on tumblr OR other places}, even if the author says they don't mind. I'm all for this, and I'd totally make use of it on either side.

[nogoaway]

this is a great idea.

ETA: i also wouldn't mind having some kind of author/beta matching service post, if that makes any sense. i have no idea how to go about finding a beta.

[anneapocalypse]

Oh, this is a great idea also, and certainly something we could incorporate!

[hokuton_punch]

I like this idea very much! I'm not much good at giving crit myself (though I can do a decent SPaG beta), but I love getting it.

[ausphin]

Definitely would approve!